LawCite Search | LawCite Markup Tool | Help | Feedback Law Cite

Ltd "In view of the award passed by the undersigned arbitrators adjudicating upon all their disputes this C P C j-- (a) (**40)*Chitaley, S 115, N 9, Pt 3 suit be dismissed with no order as to costs The (*41) Mulla, Page 420 Pt (p) a * ejectment proceedings taken by Jumo shall likewise (b) ('40) Chitaley, Sch II Para 17, N 3, Pts 3 be dismissed with r o order as to costs ** to 5; Para 20 N 5 Pt 1 Para 21 N 7 i The objections ti ken to this award on behalf of (c) ('40) Chitaley, Sch II Para 21 N 7 the present applicant before the learned Judge in the lower Court were that the award did not decide the dispute between the parties, and it was not an A I R (29) 1942 Sind 45 award because it c id not relate even in part to the subject-matter of the other award under the Arbi Davis 0 J and Weston J, tration Act, that the award was bad, and that it was coloured by matters extraneous to the suit, and Nabibux Muhammad Sulleman and that as it was bad on the face of it, there was no others -- Applicants , award at all We think the two awards must be taken together and that as the first award is found v to be invalid, the second award, which is depen Emperor dant upon the fiist, cannot stand Both clearly Criminal Revn Applns     18

Cases Referring to this Case

Case Name	Citation(s)	Court	Jurisdiction	Date	Full Text †		Citation Index
Maganlal Pranjivan Mehta v Mrs Champakunvar Ratilal Mehta	[1952] BurLawRp 19; [1952] BLR (HC) 192	Burma Law Reports	Myanmar	12 Mar 1952	AsianLII		1
Emperor v Birdichand Chunnilal	[1947] AllINRprNag 83; [1948] AIR Nag 244	All India Reporter - Nagpur	India - Maharashtra	24 Sep 1947	AsianLII
Balkrishna Murlidhar Hadap v Emperor	[1946] AllINRprNag 39; 49 Cr LJ 331	All India Reporter - Nagpur	India	29 Jun 1946	AsianLII
Vishnubhotla Ramayya v Sajja Namayya	[1942] AllINRprMad 89; [1943] AIR Mad 165	All India Reporter - Madras	India - Tamil Nadu	27 Jul 1942	AsianLII
Kesarichand Kaverlal v S H G Nayudu	[1942] AllINRprMad 90; [1943] AIR Mad 167	All India Reporter - Madras	India - Tamil Nadu	3 Mar 1942	AsianLII
Maharani Gurucharan Kaur of Nabha v Province of Madras	[1942] AllINRprMad 329; [1942] AIR Mad 539	All India Reporter - Madras	India - Tamil Nadu	6 Feb 1942	AsianLII
Gohram Shambay v Jumo Obhayo	[1942] AllINRprSind 15	All India Reporter - Sind	India	9 Sep 1941	AsianLII
Nabibux Muhammad Sulleman v Emperor	[1942] AllINRprSind 16	All India Reporter - Sind	India	4 Jul 1941	AsianLII
Emperor v Mangharam Ghumanmal Thadhani	[1941] AllINRprSind 64	All India Reporter - Sind	India	4 Oct 1940	AsianLII
Devinder Singh v Punjab Through Cbi	[2016] INSC 314	Supreme Court of India	India	25 Apr 2016	LIIofIndia
Prof Nkganguly v Cbi New Delhi	[2015] INSC 815	Supreme Court of India	India	19 Nov 2015	LIIofIndia
Om Prakash v Jharkhand & Anr	[2012] INSC 552	Supreme Court of India	India	26 Sep 2012	LIIofIndia
Eastern Book Co v DB Modak & Anr	[2007] INSC 1260	Supreme Court of India	India	12 Dec 2007	LIIofIndia
Shri Mahesh Gaonkar, Police Inspector, Panaji Goa v Shri DH Kenaudekar and Anr - Crir / 42 / 2006	[2006] INGAHC 320	High Court of Bombay at Goa	India	16 Nov 2006	LIIofIndia
Sankaran Moitra v SMT Sadhna Das & Anr	[2006] INSC 145	Supreme Court of India	India	24 Mar 2006	LIIofIndia
Romesh Lal Jain v Naginder Singh Rana	[2005] INSC 618	Supreme Court of India	India	28 Oct 2005	LIIofIndia
Subhash Singh Thakurshyam Kishore Garikapattichandrakant an v State	[1997] INSC 815	Supreme Court of India	India	6 Nov 1997	LIIofIndia
Ujs Chopra v Bombay	[1955] INSC 21; [1955] 2 SCR 94; AIR 1955 SC 633	Supreme Court of India	India	25 Mar 1955	LIIofIndia		11