LawCite Search | LawCite Markup Tool | Help | Feedback Law Cite

Berkenkotter vs Court of Appeals     55

Cases Referring to this Case

Case Name †	Citation(s)	Court	Jurisdiction	Date	Full Text		Citation Index
Amadeo Garcia v Court of Appeals, People's Homesite & Housing Corporation, Elpidio Ungria, Catalina Capinding, and Bruno Subdiaga	[1977] PHSC 128	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	26 May 1977	AsianLII
Aquilina San Pedro, Cosme San Pedro, Norberto San Pedro, Flora San Pedro, Gregoria San Pedro, Felicidad San Pedro, Guillermo San Pedro, Ricardo San Pedro, Nestor Sta Maria, Emelita Sta Maria, Gregorio San Pedro, Jeremias San Pedro, Anatolia San Pedro, Eutiquio San Pedro, Reynaldo San Pedro, Cesario San Pedro, Rogelio San Pedro, Isabela Sarmiento, Elpidio Sarmiento, Numeriano Sarmiento, Gerardo Sarmiento, Bromio Sarmiento, Ana Sarmiento, Dalmacio Palad, Claudia Palad, Leonila Palad, Napoleon Palad, Emilio Cruz, Leonora Cruz, Quinciano Cruz, Cecilia Correa, Cesar Correa, Fausta Castillo, Juan Castillo, Fabian Castillo, Roman Castillo, Teofila Castillo, Emilio Castillo, Maria Castillo, Paula Tolentino, Isabela Batisan, Silverio Batisan, Priscila Manalang, Mercedes Manalang, Rolando Chiu, and JM Diaz Realty Co v the Honorable Court of Appeals and Alejandro Mamot		Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	31 Aug 1976	AsianLII
Aquilina San Pedro, Cosme San Pedro, Norberto San Pedro, Flora San Pedro, Gregoria San Pedro, Felicidad San Pedro, Guillermo San Pedro, Ricardo San Pedro, Nestor Sta Maria, Emelita Sta Maria, Gregorio San Pedro, Jeremias San Pedro, Anatolia San Pedro, Eutiquio San Pedro, Reynaldo San Pedro, Cesario San Pedro, Rogelio San Pedro, Isabela Sarmiento, Elpidio Sarmiento, Numeriano Sarmiento, Gerardo Sarmiento, Bromio Sarmiento, Ana Sarmiento, Dalmacio Palad, Claudia Palad, Leonila Palad, Napoleon Palad, Emilio Cruz, Leonora Cruz, Quinciano Cruz, Cecilia Correa, Cesar Correa, Fausta Castillo, Juan Castillo, Fabian Castillo, Roman Castillo, Teofila Castillo, Emilio Castillo, Maria Castillo, Paula Tolentino, Isabela Batisan, Silverio Batisan, Priscila Manalang, Mercedes Manalang, Rolando Chiu, and JM Diaz Realty Co v the Honorable Court of Appeals and Alejandro Mamot - GR		Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	31 Aug 1976	AsianLII
Avelino G Gregorio and Irene J Gregorio, substituted Appellees for the deceased Eusebio Gregorio v Court of Appeals	[1976] PHSC 311	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	29 Oct 1976	AsianLII
Avelino G Gregorio and Irene J Gregorio, substituted Appellees for the deceased Eusebio Gregorio v Court of Appeals - GR	[1976] PHSC 566	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	29 Oct 1976	AsianLII
Carlota Delgado Vda De Dela Rosa v Court of Appeals, Heirs of Marciana Rustia Vda De Damian, namely: Guillermo R Damian and Jose R Damian; Heirs of Hortencia Rustia Cruz, namely: Teresita Cruz-Sison, Horacio R Cruz, Josefina Cruz-Rodil, Amelia Cruz-Enriquez and Fidel R Cruz, JR; Heirs of Roman Rustia, namely: Josefina Rustia-Albano, Virginia Rustia-Paraiso, Roman Rustia, JR , Sergio Rustia, Francisco Rustia, Leticia Rustia-Miranda; Guillermina R Rustia and Guillerma Rustia-Alaras		Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	10 Oct 1997	AsianLII
Carlota Delgado Vda De Dela Rosa v Court of Appeals, Heirs of Marciana Rustia Vda De Damian, namely: Guillermo R Damian and Jose R Damian; Heirs of Hortencia Rustia Cruz, namely: Teresita Cruz-Sison, Horacio R Cruz, Josefina Cruz-Rodil, Amelia Cruz-Enriquez and Fidel R Cruz, JR; Heirs of Roman Rustia, namely: Josefina Rustia-Albano, Virginia Rustia-Paraiso, Roman Rustia, JR , Sergio Rustia, Francisco Rustia, Leticia Rustia-Miranda; Guillermina R Rustia and Guillerma Rustia-Alaras - GR		Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	10 Oct 1997	AsianLII
Commercial Union Assurance Co Ltd and North British & Mercantile Insurance Co Ltd v Lepanto Consolidated Mining Co and the Honorable Court of Appeals	[1978] PHSC 329	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	30 Oct 1978	AsianLII
Compagnie Des Messageries Maritimes v the Court of Appeals and a a R Botelho	[1980] PHSC 300	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	11 Sep 1980	AsianLII
Dolores De Mesa Abad and Cesar De Mesa Tioseco v the Court of Appeals and Honoria Empaynado, Et ALS	[1985] PHSC 263	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	9 Jul 1985	AsianLII
Emperatriz Vestal Lopez, Florencio, Marval, Fermin, Adolfa, Vicenta, Jose and Severa, all surnamed Lopez v Honorable Court of Appeals, Crisostomo Rosales and Fortunato Malanguis	[1977] PHSC 39	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	28 Feb 1977	AsianLII
Florentina Nuguid Vda De Haberer v Federico Martinez, Baldomero Manalo, Faustino Bagalawis, Federico Sta Teresa, Angelito King, Gregorio Del Rosario, Leodovico Torres, Leon Soriano, Santiago Tumang, Luis Pastor, Cristino Libramante and the Hon Court of Appeals	[1975] PHSC 17	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	29 Jan 1975	AsianLII
Francisco Manipol and Lucia Manipol v Hon Court of Appeals and Republic of the Philippines	[1979] PHSC 112	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	30 Apr 1979	AsianLII
Frank Raymond Krueger, assisted by his guardian ad litem, Francis Austria Krueger v the Hon Court of Appeals, Bernardo o Valdez and Lucina Siapno	[1976] PHSC 5	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	20 Jan 1976	AsianLII
Generosa Cawit and Braulio Lumayno v the Hon Court of Appeals and Noe, Tomas and Gerardo, all surnamed Dino	[1988] PHSC 795	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	4 Oct 1988	AsianLII
Gertrudes l Del Rosario v Dorotea o Conanan and Marilou Del Rosario	[1977] PHSC 70	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	30 Mar 1977	AsianLII
Graciano Santos v Court of Appeals, Philippine National Bank, Spouses Mariano Ilagan and Maria Flores and the Provincial Sheriff of Tarlac province	[1979] PHSC 147	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	25 May 1979	AsianLII
Gregorio v Pajarillo and Rosa o De Pajarillo v the Court of Appeals and Proceso J Arevalo	[1976] PHSC 338	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	29 Nov 1976	AsianLII
Gregorio v Pajarillo and Rosa o De Pajarillo v the Court of Appeals and Proceso J Arevalo - GR	[1976] PHSC 593	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	29 Nov 1976	AsianLII
Habaluyas Enterprises, Inc and Pedro Habaluyas v Judge Maximo M Japson, Manila Regional Trial Court, Branch 36; Shugo Noda & Co , Ltd , and Shuya Noda	[1986] PHSC 74	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	30 May 1986	AsianLII
Heirs of the Late Florentina Nuguid Vda De Haberer v Court of Appeals	[1981] PHSC 163	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	26 May 1981	AsianLII
Hon Court of Appeals, Beatriz Fontanosa, Reginaldo Flores, Annabelle o Aboitiz, Emelio M R Osmena, Luis M Aboitiz, John Henry Osmena, Nicolas Tan, Antonio W Dihiansan, Tessie Villaceran Ang, Bernarda Fontanosa and Custodio Quinanahan v Hon Court of Appeals, Beatriz Fontanosa, Reginaldo Flores, Annabelle o Aboitiz, Emelio M R Osmena, Luis M Aboitiz, John Henry Osmena, Nicolas Tan, Antonio W Dihiansan, Tessie Villaceran Ang, Bernarda Fontanosa and Custodio Quinanahan		Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	30 Apr 1976	AsianLII
Hon Court of Appeals, Beatriz Fontanosa, Reginaldo Flores, Annabelle o Aboitiz, Emelio M R Osmena, Luis M Aboitiz, John Henry Osmena, Nicolas Tan, Antonio W Dihiansan, Tessie Villaceran Ang, Bernarda Fontanosa and Custodio Quinanahan v Hon Court of Appeals, Beatriz Fontanosa, Reginaldo Flores, Annabelle o Aboitiz, Emelio M R Osmena, Luis M Aboitiz, John Henry Osmena, Nicolas Tan, Antonio W Dihiansan, Tessie Villaceran Ang, Bernarda Fontanosa and Custodio Quinanahan - GR		Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	30 Apr 1976	AsianLII
Isabel Andaya v the Court of Appeals and Benedicto Ramos	[1976] PHSC 135	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	5 May 1976	AsianLII
Isabel Andaya v the Court of Appeals and Benedicto Ramos - GR	[1976] PHSC 391	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	5 May 1976	AsianLII
J Amado Araneta v Alfonso Doronila, a Doronila Resources Development, Inc , and Court of Appeals	[1976] PHSC 244	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	24 Aug 1976	AsianLII
J Amado Araneta v Alfonso Doronila, a Doronila Resources Development, Inc , and Court of Appeals - GR	[1976] PHSC 500	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	24 Aug 1976	AsianLII
Jesus G Cabalza v Court of Appeals	[1976] PHSC 318	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	29 Oct 1976	AsianLII
Jesus G Cabalza v Court of Appeals - GR	[1976] PHSC 573	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	29 Oct 1976	AsianLII
Jesus P Garcia Court of Appeals, Jose Recoleto and Judith a Recoleto	[1977] PHSC 106	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	29 Apr 1977	AsianLII
Jesus R Aznar and Aurora Timber Industries Corporation v the Hon Court of Appeals and Ong Brothers Lumber Co , Inc	[1978] PHSC 301	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	30 Sep 1978	AsianLII
Jesusa Liquido, Clementina Liquido, Clementino Liquido, Adelendez Liquido, Francisco Liquido, Felicisima Liquido, Juan Liquido, JR , and Jovita Liquido v the Hon Court of Appeals, Spouses Tarcisio Ensomo and Leonida Eder, and Spouses Romeo Gillo and Teresita Cabana Gillo	[1982] PHSC 535	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	23 Oct 1982	AsianLII
Jose P Tambunting and Josefina Arnaiz v the Hon Court of Appeals, Francisco Parulan Sr , Felisa De La Cruz and Francisco Parulan, Jr	[1976] PHSC 53	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	27 Feb 1976	AsianLII
Juan C Pimentel and Salud De Los Reyes v Honorable Court of Appeals, Paulino o Oriel, and MacAria Ruiz	[1975] PHSC 178	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	27 Jun 1975	AsianLII
Luzon Concrete Products, Inc , Salvador f Cunanan, Cesar S Gopes, Vitali H De Guzman, Leopoldo v Bernabe, Alejandro Q Tablante, Victorio l Punla, and Angel Viri v Hon Court of Appeals, Hon Fernando Bartolome, Presiding Judge, Court of First Instance of Pampanga, Branch v, Fifth Judicial District, Provincial Sheriff of Pampanga, Eutiquiano M Baula, Rev FR Manuel Q Baula, Pedro M Baula, Concordia Baula, Laureano M Baula, Spouses Marcelina S Tablante, and Bartolome Tablante, Spouses Miguela b Santos and Anasto Santos, Spouses Leonila b Datu and Carlos Datu, and Spouses Felisa b Tayag and Armentario Tayag		Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	20 Mar 1985	AsianLII
Manuel Yap v Hon Court of Appeals, Raymond and Lydia Tomassi	[1982] PHSC 292	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	19 Jul 1982	AsianLII
Maria Alicia Leuterio v Court of Appeals and Heirs of Benito Leuterio	[1977] PHSC 291	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	30 Sep 1977	AsianLII
Maria Villanueva and Lino Dizon v the Court of Appeals and Gervacio Luis Que	[1975] PHSC 377	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	28 Nov 1975	AsianLII
Maria Villanueva and Lino Dizon vs the Court of Appeals and Gervacio Luis Que - GR No l-29719	[1975] PHSC 431	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	28 Nov 1975	AsianLII
Natalia De Las Alas, assisted by her husband, Aurelio Panganiban, Avelina De Las Alas, assisted by her husband, Francisco Salazar, Norma De Las Alas, Peregrina De Las Alas, assisted by her husband, Hernando Ganac, Bienvenido De Las Alas, and Narciso Panganiban v Court of Appeals, Honorable Benjamin Relova, in his capacity as Judge, Court of First Instance of Batangas (Lipa City Branch), Eugenio De Las Alas, Pablo De Las Alas, Perseveranda De Las Alas, Felisa De Las Alas, assisted by her husband, Abundio Rojales Arsenio Pe Ñ Aflorida, Isabel Pe Ñ Aflorida, Pacita Pe Ñ Aflorida, Angela Pe Ñ Aflorida, Marino Soberano, Teodoro Soberano, Mercedes Soberano, assisted by her husband, Juliano Bulanade, Petronila Soberano, assisted by her husband, Benjamin Ilagan, Josefa Soberano, Orencio Soberano, Milagros Soberano, assisted by her husband, Domingo Jamir, Jose Soberano, JR , Purificacion Soberano, assisted by her husband, Antonio Fabio, and Natividad Soberano, assisted by her husband, Carlos Balingit		Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	16 May 1978	AsianLII
Nelita Fonseca and Arturo Tuason v the Hon Court of Appeals and Adolfo AL Gutierrez	[1988] PHSC 691	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	30 Aug 1988	AsianLII
Nicolas Galdo v the Honorable Eulalio D Rosete, Presiding Judge of the Court of First Instance of Misamis Oriental, Branch Ix, and Rosario b Roa	[1978] PHSC 197	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	25 Jul 1978	AsianLII
Pacific Life Assurance Corporation, doing business under the name and style of "Pacific Memorial Plan" v Concordia, Franklin, Norman, Nelson and Emil, all surnamed Sison	[1998] PHSC 716	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	20 Nov 1998	AsianLII
Philippine Virginia Tobacco Administration (Pvta) v Hon Walfrido De Los Angeles as Judge of the Court of First Instance of Rizal (Quezon City, Branch IV), and Abra Agricultural Association, Inc , (Bangued, Abra)	[1974] PHSC 404	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	31 Oct 1974	AsianLII
Pilar De Guzman, Rolando Gestuvo, and Minerva Gestuvo v the Hon Court of Appeals, the Hon Judge Pedro JL Bautista, Presiding Judge of the Court of First Instance of Rizal, Branch III, Pasay City, and Leonida P Singh	[1985] PHSC 288	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	23 Jul 1985	AsianLII
Rafael Libongco and Belen Libongco v the Honorable Court of Appeals and Raul Casumpang Y Islao	[1977] PHSC 48	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	28 Feb 1977	AsianLII
Republic of the Philippines (Bureau of Forestry) v Court of Appeals, Tomas Carag, Antonia Baculing, Muviel b Carag and Development Bank of the Philippines (Isabela Branch) and Antonia Lacerna, Margarita Taguba and Philippine National Bank(Aparri Branch)	[1975] PHSC 331	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	21 Oct 1975	AsianLII
Republic of the Philippines, represented by the Director of Lands v the Honorable Court of Appeals, Melitona Alagad, spouses Carmen Alagad and Espiridion Kolimlim, Justo Alagad, Carlos Alagad, spouses Librada Alagad and Emerson Abano, Demetrio Alagad, Antonio Alagad, the Register of Deeds of Laguna, the Municipal Judge of Pila, Laguna and the Provincial Sheriff of Laguna	[1982] PHSC 619	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	19 Nov 1982	AsianLII
Republic of the Philippines v the Honorable Court of Appeals, Alfredo v De Ocampo, and Oscar Anglo	[1978] PHSC 138	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	31 May 1978	AsianLII
Rogelia, Rolando, Lorna, Eva, Rafael, Ebenezer Evangeline and Yolanda, all surnamed Perartilla v Court of Appeals and Heirs of Gonzalo De La Pe Ñ a, namely, Elsa P Cuadra, Lourdes De La Pena, Angeles De La Pe Ñ a, Cosette P Bernabe, Mario De La Pena and Ana Nita De La Pe Ñ a	[1983] PHSC 452	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	27 Oct 1983	AsianLII
Rosario Lacsamana, Florencio Bautista, Quirico Paclibar, Eduardo Ocampo, Julio Barizo, Pedro Pangilinan, v the Honorable Second Special Cases Division of the Intermediate Appellate Court, Anigia i Cruz,	[1986] PHSC 201	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	26 Aug 1986	AsianLII
Segundo Abando v Court of Appeals,* Apolonio S Robles, and Isaac Tisbe	[1978] PHSC 140	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	31 May 1978	AsianLII
Sotero Recto v the Honorable Court of Appeals (Fifth Division) and Claudio Francisco	[1982] PHSC 496	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	30 Sep 1982	AsianLII
Trans-Philippines, Inc v Court of Appeals and Luzon Stevedoring Corporation	[1977] PHSC 218	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	29 Jul 1977	AsianLII
Trans World Airlines, Inc v the Court of Appeals and Air India	[1981] PHSC 238	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	10 Aug 1981	AsianLII