Republic of the Philippines v Hon Mamindiara P Mangotara, in his capacity as Presiding Judge of the Regional Trial Court, Branch 1, Iligan City, Lanao del Norte, and Maria Cristina Fertilizer Corporation, and the Philippines National Bank/Land Trade Realty Corporation Vs National Power Corporation and National Transmission Corporation (Transco)/National Power Corporation Vs Hon Court of Appeals (Special Twenty-Third Division, Cagayan de Oro City) and Land Trade Realty Corporation/National Transmission Corporation Vs Hon Court of Appeals (Special Twenty-Third Division, Cagayan de Oro City) and Land Trade Realty Corporation

[2010] PHSC 619

Supreme Court of the Philippines

Philippines

7th July, 2010

Legislation Cited

Legislation Name	Provision
Constitution

Cases and Articles Cited

Case Name †	Citation(s)	Court	Jurisdiction	Date	Full Text	Citation Index
(2005) 449 Scra 65	(2005) 449 SCRA 65	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 2005		9
(2005) 465 Scra 82	(2005) 465 SCRA 82	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 2005		2
(2005) 465 Scra 308	(2005) 465 SCRA 308	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 2005		2
(2005) 473 Scra 363	(2005) 473 SCRA 363	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 2005		3
(2005) 474 Scra 485	(2005) 474 SCRA 485	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 2005		7
(2005) 475 Scra 305	(2005) 475 SCRA 305	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 2005		9
(2005) 475 Scra 608	(2005) 475 SCRA 608	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 2005		11
(2005) 477 Scra 725	(2005) 477 SCRA 725	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 2005		4
(2007) 520 Scra 346	(2007) 520 SCRA 346	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 2007		8
(2007) 524 Scra 641	(2007) 524 SCRA 641	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 2007		5
(2008) 559 Scra 186	(2008) 559 SCRA 186	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 2008		1
(2009) 581 Scra 70	(2009) 581 SCRA 70	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 2009		2
[1974] Sec 10	[1974] SEC 10		United States	circa 1974		2
[1976] Sec 13	[1976] SEC 13		United States	circa 1976		2
Aclon v Court of Appeals	436 Phil 219		Philippines			5
Agapay v Palang	342 Phil 302		Philippines			7
Amagan v Marayag	383 Phil 486		Philippines			5
Bukidnon Doctors’ Hospital, Inc., v. Metropolitan Bank & Trust Co	501 Phil 516		Philippines			1
Cabrera v Court of Appeals	335 Phil 19; 267 SCRA 339	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			70
Cacho v CA	269 SCRA 159	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			15
Cacho v Court of Appeals	336 Phil 154		Philippines			5
Cacho v Court of Appeals	342 Phil 383		Philippines			1
Calacala v Republic	502 Phil 681		Philippines			2
Caro v Sucaldito	497 Phil 879		Philippines			1
Ceroferr Realty Corporation v Court of Appeals	426 Phil 522		Philippines			6
De Knecht v Court of Appeals	352 Phil 833		Philippines			3
Estate of the Late Jesus S Yujuico v Republic	(2007) 537 SCRA 513	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 2007		8
Gochan v Gochan	423 Phil 491		Philippines	circa 2007		7
Gordula v Court of Appeals	348 Phil 670		Philippines	circa 2007		7
Government of the United States	28 Phil 616		Philippines	circa 2007		3
Heirs of Eugenio Lopez, Sr v Enriquez	(2005) 449 SCRA 173	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 2005		11
Heirs of Tuazon v Court of Appeals	465 Phil 114		Philippines			4
Heirs of Yaptinchay v Del Rosario	363 Phil 393		Philippines			4
Hilario v Court of Appeals	329 Phil 202		Philippines			7
Legarda v Savellano	241 Phil 988		Philippines			1
Levi Strauss & Co v Clinton Apparelle, Inc	(2005) 470 SCRA 236	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 2005		13
Metropolitan Waterworks and Sewerage System v Court of Appeals	227 Phil 585		Philippines			2
Navales v Abaya	484 Phil 367		Philippines			1
NBI - Microsoft Corporation v Hwang	499 Phil 423		Philippines			1
Northcastle Properties and Estate Corporation v Judge Paas	375 Phil 564		Philippines			2
of Ignacio Conti v Court of Appeals	360 Phil 536		Philippines			2
Peltan Development, Inc v Court of Appeals	336 Phil 824		Philippines			7
Portugal v Portugal-Beltran	(2005) 467 SCRA 184	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 2005		8
Republic	(2006) 503 SCRA 522	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 2006		3
Republic of the Philippines v Heirs of Angeles	439 Phil 349		Philippines			5
Republic of the Phils v CFI of Lanao del Norte, Br IV	216 Phil 385		Philippines			1
Republic v Court of Appeals	171 SCRA 721	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			16
Republic v Court of Appeals	183 SCRA 620	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			15
Republic v De la Cruz	160-A Phil 374		Philippines			1
Republic v Guerrero	(2006) 485 SCRA 424	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 2006		10
Republic v Heirs of Felipe Alejaga, Sr	441 Phil 656		Philippines			4
Republic v Holazo	480 Phil 828		Philippines			3
Republic v Mina	114 SCRA 945	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			12
Republic v Ruiz	(1968) 23 SCRA 348	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1968		15
Reyes v Court of Appeals	356 Phil 606		Philippines			7
Rivera	100 Phil 364		Philippines			10
Samonte v Court of Appeals	413 Phil 487		Philippines			4
Solivio v Court of Appeals	182 SCRA 119	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			17
Spouses Mathay v Court of Appeals	356 Phil 870		Philippines			5
Spouses Morandarte v Court of Appeals	479 Phil 870		Philippines			3
Sta Ana v Menla	1 SCRA 1294; 111 Phil 947	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			13
Sta Lucia Realty and Development, Inc v Cabrigas	411 Phil 369		Philippines			9
Vda De Manguerra v Risos	(2008) 563 SCRA 499	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 2008		3
Velarde v Social Justice Society	(2004) 428 SCRA 283	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 2004		26
Vergara v Court of Appeals	377 Phil 337		Philippines			1
Wilmon Auto Supply Corporation v Court of Appeals	208 SCRA 108	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			40
28 Phil 105	28 Phil 105		Philippines			4
28 Phil 617	28 Phil 617		Philippines			2
116 Phil 765	116 Phil 765		Philippines			1
319 Phil 648	319 Phil 648		Philippines			1
391 Phil 575	391 Phil 575		Philippines			2
496 Phil 456	496 Phil 456		Philippines			1
500 Phil 288	500 Phil 288		Philippines			1

LawCite: Privacy | Disclaimers | Conditions of Use | Acknowledgements | Feedback