Ernesto b Francisco, JR Nagmamalasakit NA Mga Manananggol NG Mga Manggagawang Pilipino, Inc , Its Officers and Members, petitioner-in-intervention, World War II Veterans Legionaries of the Philippines, Inc , petitioner-in-intervention, v the House of Representatives, Represented by Speaker Jose G De Venecia, the Senate, Represented by Senate President Franklin M Drilon, Representative Gilberto C Teodoro, JR and Representative Felix William b Fuentebella

[2003] PHSC 592

Supreme Court of the Philippines

Philippines

10th November, 2003

Legislation Cited

Legislation Name	Provision
Constitution

Cases and Articles Cited

Case Name	Citation(s)	Court	Jurisdiction	Date †	Full Text	Citation Index
Estrada v Desierto	(2001) 356 SCRA 108	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 2001		13
Bayan (Bagong Alyansang Makabayan) v Zamora	(2000) 342 SCRA 449	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 2000		25
Gonzales v Narvasa	(2000) 337 SCRA 733	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 2000		14
Nixon v United States	506 US 224; 113 SCt 732; 122 L Ed 2d 1; 113 SCt 7; 122 L Ed 3	United States Supreme Court	United States	13 Jan 1993	WorldLII	49
Albano v Reyes	(1989) 175 SCRA 264	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines	circa 1989		15
Baker v Carr	369 US 186; 82 SCt 691; 7 L Ed 2d 633; 7 L Ed 663; 82 SCt Rep 69; 7 L Ed 2; 7 L Ed 2d 663	United States Supreme Court	United States	26 Mar 1962	WorldLII	1055
United States v Smith	286 US 6; 76 L Ed 954; 52 SCt 475	United States Supreme Court	United States	2 May 1932	WorldLII	15
Maxwell v Dow	176 US 581; 44 L Ed 597; 20 SCt 448	United States Supreme Court	United States	26 Feb 1900	WorldLII	88
United States v Ballin	144 US 1; 36 L Ed 321; 12 SCt 507	United States Supreme Court	United States	29 Feb 1892	WorldLII	28
Marbury v Madison	5 US 137; 1 Cranch 137; 2 L Ed 135; 2 L Ed 60; 6 Pet 241	United States Supreme Court	United States	1 Feb 1803	WorldLII	1029
citing Industrial Generating Co v Jenkins	410 SW 2d 658	US				3
Chavez v Public Estates Authority	384 SCRA 152	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			27
Household Finance Corporation v Shaffner	356 Mo 808; 203 SW 2d 734	US	United States - Missouri			3
Vide concurring opinion of Justice Vicente Mendoza in Estrada vDesierto	353 SCRA 452	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			10
Del Mar v Philippine Amusement and Gaming Corporation	346 SCRA 485	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			21
JG Summit Holdings, Inc v Court of Appeals	345 SCRA 143	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			11
Integrated Bar of the Philippines v Zamora	338 SCRA 81	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			24
Firestone Ceramics, Inc v Court of Appeals	313 SCRA 522	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			14
Chavez v PCGG	299 SCRA 744	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			18
Santiago v Guingona	298 SCRA 756	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			22
Ashwander v Tennessee Valley Authority	297 US 288; 80 L Ed 688; 56 SCt 466; 80 L Ed 2d 688	United States Supreme Court	United States		Westlaw	768
(Telecommunications and Broadcast Attorneys of the Philippines, Inc vs Commission on Elections	289 SCRA 337	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			13
Tatad v Secretary of the Department of Energy	281 SCRA 330	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			32
Arroyo v De Venecia	277 SCRA 268	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			12
Tañada v. Angara	272 SCRA 18	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			47
Santiago v Comelec	270 SCRA 106	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			11
Board of Optometry v Colet	260 SCRA 88	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			18
Kilosbayan, Inc vs Morato	250 SCRA 130	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			13
People v Veneracion	249 SCRA 244	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			10
Kilosbayan, Inc vs Morato	246 SCRA 540	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			37
Tatad v Garcia, Jr	243 SCRA 436	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			22
KMU Labor Center v Garcia, Jr	239 SCRA 386	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			19
Enriquez	235 SCRA 506	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			35
Inc v Guingona	232 SCRA 110	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			50
Philippine Judges Association v Prado	227 SCRA 703	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			19
Garcia v Comelec	227 SCRA 100	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			14
Joya v PCGG	225 SCRA 568	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			20
Joya v PCGG	225 SCRA 368	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			2
Oposa v Factoran	224 SCRA 792	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			39
Macasiano v National Housing Authority	224 SCRA 236	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			25
Santos III v Northwest Orient Airlines	210 SCRA 256	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			19
Guingona v PCGG	207 SCRA 659	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			13
Carpio v Executive Secretary	206 SCRA 290	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			12
Bengzon v Senate Blue Ribbon Committee	203 SCRA 767	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			9
Bondoc v Pineda	201 SCRA 792	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			10
Osme ñ a v Comelec	199 SCRA 750	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			21
Basco v Pagcor	197 SCRA 52	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			46
Guingona v Carague	196 SCRA 221	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			11
Civil Liberties Union v Executive Secretary	194 SCRA 317	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			29
Ordillo v Commission on Elections	192 SCRA 100	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			3
Luz Farms v Secretary of the Department of Agrarian Reform	192 SCRA 51	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			28
Gonzales v Macaraig	191 SCRA 452	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			14
Coseteng v Mitra, Jr	187 SCRA 377	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			8
Daza v Singson	180 SCRA 496	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			20
Magsaysay-Labrador v Court of Appeals	180 SCRA 266	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			19
Marcos v Manglapus	177 SCRA 668	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			12
Construction and Development Corporation v Laron	176 SCRA 240	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			25
Province of Tayabas v Perez	175 SCRA 343; 66 Phil 467	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			121
Bulig-bulig Kita Kamag-Anak Assoc v Sulpicio Lines	173 SCRA 514	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			2
National Economic Protectionism Association v Ongpin	171 SCRA 657	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			12
Vide Abbas v Senate Electoral Tribunal	166 SCRA 651	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			2
Baranda v Gustilo	165 SCRA 757	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			14
Pilipinas, Inc v Tan	163 SCRA 371	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			25
Re: Request of the Heirs of the Passengers of Do ñ a Paz	159 SCRA 623	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			4
Nitafan v Commissioner of Internal Revenue	152 SCRA 284	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			5
House International Building Tenants Association, Inc v Intermediate Appellate Court	151 SCRA 703	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			14
Legaspi v Civil Service Commission	150 SCRA 530	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			22
Ynot v Intermediate Appellate Court	148 SCRA 659	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			14
Demetria v Alba	148 SCRA 208	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			8
Ramirez v Macandong	144 SCRA 462	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			34
141 Scra 263	141 SCRA 263	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			4
Ta ñ ada v Tuvera	136 SCRA 27	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			31
Weberpals v Jenny	133 NE 62; 300 Ill 145		United States			5
Gonzales v Hechanova	118 Phil 1065		Philippines			6
Commonwealth v Ralph	111 PA 365; 3 ATL 220		United States			8
Pascual v Secretary of Public Works	110 Phil 331		Philippines			39
Osme ñ a v Pendatun	109 Phil 863		Philippines			12
Los Angeles County Winans	109 P 640					4
Tanada v Cuenco	103 Phil 1051		Philippines			50
Dumlao v Comelec	95 SCRA 392	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			57
citing Gibson vs Revilla	92 SCRA 219	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			7
Montenegro v Casta ñ eda	91 Phil 882		Philippines			16
Chinese Flour Importers Association v Price Stabilization Board	89 Phil 439		Philippines			8
Perfecto v Meer	85 Phil 552		Philippines			5
Araneta v Dinglasan	84 Phil 368		Philippines			57
Avelino v Cuenco	83 Phil 17		Philippines			18
82 Phil 771	82 Phil 771		Philippines			7
De la Llana v Comelec	80 SCRA 525	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			5
Vargas v Rilloraza,	80 Phil 297		Philippines			6
Vera vs Avelino	77 Phil 192		Philippines			35
Sotto v Commission on Elections	76 Phil 516		Philippines			21
Sanidad v Comelec	73 SCRA 333	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			33
Gold Creek Mining Corporation v Rodriguez	66 Phil 259		Philippines			28
Angara v Electoral Commission	63 Phil 139		Philippines			101
Consolidated Bank and Trust Co	58 SCRA 559	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			25
Javellana v Executive Secretary	50 SCRA 30	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			34
Plebiscite Cases (Planas v Comelec	49 SCRA 105	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			6
Borlasa v Polistico	47 Phil 345		Philippines			30
Alejandrino v Quezon	46 Phil 83		Philippines			23
citing Gallego vs Kapisanan Timbulan ng mga Manggagawa	46 Off Gaz Pat Office 4245		United States			3
Tan v Macapagal	43 SCRA 677	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			24
US v Ang Tang Ho	43 Phil 1		Philippines			14
Lansang v Garcia	42 SCRA 448	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			29
McDaniel v Apacible	42 Phil 749		Philippines			20
Concepcion vs Paredes	42 Phil 599		Philippines			20
Tolentino vs Comelec	41 SCRA 702	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			19
40 Scra 58	40 SCRA 58	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			6
Land Tenure Administration	31 SCRA 413	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			75
Gonzales v Comelec	21 SCRA 774	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			23
Philconsa vs Mathay	18 SCRA 300; 124 Phil 890	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			21
16 CJS 231	16 CJS 231		United States			2
Pelaez v Auditor General	15 SCRA 569	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			32
Philconsa v Gimenez	15 SCRA 479	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			19
Palay and Corn Planters Association, Inc v Feliciano	13 SCRA 377	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			25
Casanovas v Hord	8 Phil 125		Philippines			9
Cunanan v Tan, Jr	5 SCRA 1	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			6
Barcelon vs Baker	5 Phil 87		Philippines			24
Macias v Comelec	3 SCRA 1	Supreme Court of the Philippines	Philippines			8
In re Prautch	1 Phil 132		Philippines			10

LawCite: Privacy | Disclaimers | Conditions of Use | Acknowledgements | Feedback