LawCite Search | LawCite Markup Tool | Help | Feedback

Law
Cite

Cases Referring to this Case | Law Reform Reports Referring to this Case | Law Journal Articles Referring to this Case | Legislation Cited | Cases and Articles Cited

Help

Simpson Appliances (NZ) Ltd v Fisher and Paykel Ltd HC Auckland CL41/89   flag  2

[1990] NZHC 307; [1990] NZAR 241
High Court of New Zealand
New Zealand
27th April, 1990

Cases Referring to this Case

Case Name †  Citation(s) Court Jurisdiction Date Full Text Citation Index
Air New Zealand Ltd v Commerce Commission [2007] NZCA 27; [2007] 2 NZLR 494; (2007) 18 PRNZ 406 Court of Appeal of New Zealand New Zealand 28 Feb 2007 NZLII flag 62
Air New Zealand v Commerce Commission (No 6) [2004] NZHC 1010; (2004) 11 TCLR 347 High Court of New Zealand New Zealand 17 Sep 2004 NZLII flag 62
ANZ Banking Group (New Zealand) Ltd and NBNZ Holdings Ltd; Decision No 507 [2003] NZComComm 23 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 25 Sep 2003 NZLII flag
Brambles New Zealand Ltd and GE Capital Returnable Packaging Systems Ltd; Decision No 495 [2003] NZComComm 10 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 21 Mar 2003 NZLII flag
Bungy New Zealand and Pipeline Bungy; Decision No 504 [2003] NZComComm 20 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 24 Jul 2003 NZLII flag
CB Norwood Distributors Ltd and CNH Australia Pty Ltd; Decision No 522 [2004] NZComComm 522 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 18 May 2004 NZLII flag
Ceda Drycleaners Ltd v Doonan HC Auckland CP460/96 [1997] NZHC 1310; [1998] 1 NZLR 224; (1997) 3 NZ Conv C 192,641 High Court of New Zealand New Zealand 4 Sep 1997 NZLII flag 5
Cendant Corporation and Budget Group Incorporated; Decision No 482 [2002] NZComComm 32 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 6 Nov 2002 NZLII flag
Commerce Commission v Port Nelson Ltd [1995] NZHC 1130; (1995) 6 TCLR 406; (1995) 5 NZBLC 103,762 High Court of New Zealand New Zealand 2 Jun 1995 NZLII flag 117
Commerce Commission v Southern Cross Medical Care Society [2003] NZCA 248; [2004] 1 NZLR 491; (2003) 10 TCLR 824; (2003) 16 PRNZ 924 Court of Appeal of New Zealand New Zealand 29 Oct 2003 NZLII flag 49
CSR Building Products (NZ) Ltd and Ross Roofing Ltd, Rosscrete Roofing Tiles Ltd and Ross Brick & Pavers Ltd; Decision No 648 [2008] NZComComm 19 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 27 Aug 2008 NZLII flag
David Ferrier and/or New Zealand Woolscourers Ltd and Cavalier Wool Holdings Ltd and Godfrey Hirst NZ Ltd; Decision No 666 [2009] NZComComm 5 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 6 Mar 2009 NZLII flag
DFS Group Ltd and The Nuance Group; Decision No 638 [2008] NZComComm 9 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 28 Mar 2008 NZLII flag
Electricity Market Co Ltd; Decision No 280 [1996] NZComComm 16 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 13 Sep 1996 NZLII flag
epay New Zealand Limited and Ezi†Pay Limited [2012] NZComComm 13 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 15 Jun 2012 NZLII flag
Fletcher Challenge Steel Products Ltd and Steel and Tube Holdings Ltd; Decision No 376 [1999] NZComComm 30 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 4 Nov 1999 NZLII flag
Frucor Beverages Ltd and Simply Squeezed Holdings Ltd and/or Brownlie Brothers Ltd; Decision No 680 [2009] NZComComm 16 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 25 Aug 2009 NZLII flag
Genesis Power Ltd and Energy Online Ltd; Decision No 476 [2002] NZComComm 26 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 10 Oct 2002 NZLII flag
Genesis Power Ltd and Natural Gas Corporation Holdings Ltd; Decision No 490 [2003] NZComComm 5 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 4 Feb 2003 NZLII flag
Godfrey Hirst NZ Ltd v Commerce Commission [2016] NZCA 560; [2017] 2 NZLR 729 Court of Appeal of New Zealand New Zealand 30 Nov 2016 NZLII flag 14
Harmoney Ltd v Commerce Commission [2019] NZCA 355 Court of Appeal of New Zealand New Zealand 7 Aug 2019 NZLII flag 1
Holcim (New Zealand) Ltd and Atlas Resources Ltd; Decision No 513 [2003] NZComComm 29 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 20 Nov 2003 NZLII flag
Investigation into Winstone Wallboards Ltd [2014] NZComComm 75 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 22 Dec 2014 NZLII flag
Investigation report on Sky TV contracts (original un-numbered) [2013] NZComComm 54 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 8 Oct 2013 NZLII flag
ITW New Zealand Ltd and Pryda and Reid Divisions of Nylex (New Zealand) Ltd; Decision No 510 [2003] NZComComm 26 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 9 Oct 2003 NZLII flag
Market Administrator of the New Zealand Electricity Market - The Marketplace Co Ltd; Decision No 474 [2002] NZComComm 24 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 23 Dec 2002 NZLII flag
Medimedia (NZ) Ltd and Adis International Ltd; Decision No 516 [2003] NZComComm 32 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 18 Dec 2003 NZLII flag
MiTek New Zealand Ltd and Pryda New Zealand and Reid New Zealand; Decision No 512 [2003] NZComComm 28 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 13 Nov 2003 NZLII flag
National Foods Ltd and New Zealand Dairy Foods Ltd - Decision No 459 [2002] NZComComm 459 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 22 Mar 2002 NZLII flag
Natural Gas Corporation Holdings Ltd and UnitedNetworks Ltd; Decision No 470 [2002] NZComComm 20 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 23 Aug 2002 NZLII flag
New Zealand Motel Federation Incorporation and Pacifica Lodges & Inns Society Ltd; Decision No 515 [2003] NZComComm 31 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 4 Dec 2003 NZLII flag
New Zealand Steel Ltd v National Distribution Union Incorporated HC Auckland CIV 2009-404-6090 [2010] NZHC 695 High Court of New Zealand New Zealand 11 May 2010 NZLII flag
Pacific Radiology Ltd and Wakefield Radiology Ltd; Decision No 518 [2004] NZComComm 2 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 26 Feb 2004 NZLII flag
Portacom New Zealand Ltd and Transportables; Decision No 499 [2003] NZComComm 14 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 30 May 2003 NZLII flag
Procter and Gamble Distributing New Zealand and Wella New Zealand Ltd; Decision No 500 [2003] NZComComm 15 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 10 Jun 2003 NZLII flag
Redeal Ltd and Egley Electrical Co Ltd and Egley Electrical Petone Ltd; Decision No 645 [2008] NZComComm 16 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 12 Jun 2008 NZLII flag
Reyrolle Pacific Holdings Ltd and VA Tech Reyrolle Pacific Ltd; Decision No 463 [2002] NZComComm 13 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 1 Jul 2002 NZLII flag
Shell New Zealand Ltd and Mobil Oil New Zealand Ltd; Decision No 655 [2008] NZComComm 25 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 10 Oct 2008 NZLII flag
South Pacific Seeds Pty Ltd and Yates Ltd; Decision No 508 [2003] NZComComm 24 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 25 Sep 2003 NZLII flag
Southern Capital Ltd and Hirepool Ltd; Decision No 493 [2003] NZComComm 8 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 6 Mar 2003 NZLII flag
Sumitomo Forestry Co Ltd and Carter Holt Harvey Ltd (Building Supplies Division); Decision No 637 [2008] NZComComm 8 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 20 Mar 2008 NZLII flag
Telecom Corporation of New Zealand Ltd v Commerce Commission [1991] NZHC 3161; (1991) 4 TCLR 473; [1992] NZAR 193; (1991) 3 NZBLC 102,340 High Court of New Zealand New Zealand 10 Dec 1991 NZLII flag 137
Transpacific Technical Services (NZ) Ltd and Medi-Chem Waster Services Ltd; Decision No 616 [2007] NZComComm 19 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 30 Aug 2007 NZLII flag
Transpower New Zealand Ltd v Todd Energy Ltd [2007] NZCA 302 Court of Appeal of New Zealand New Zealand 20 Jul 2007 NZLII flag 57
Val Morgan Holdings Pty Ltd and Val Morgan & Co (Aust) Pty Ltd and Media Entertainment Group Ltd; Decision No 485 [2002] NZComComm 35 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 18 Dec 2002 NZLII flag
Vector Ltd and UnitedNetworks Ltd; Decision No 471 [2002] NZComComm 21 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 23 Aug 2002 NZLII flag
Vita New Zealand Ltd and Pacific Brands Holdings (NZ) Ltd; Decision No 641 [2008] NZComComm 12 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 24 Apr 2008 NZLII flag
Vodafone Mobile Ltd NZ and 900 MHZ Spectrum; Decision No 479 [2002] NZComComm 29 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 1 Nov 2002 NZLII flag
Welgas Holdings Ltd v Petroleum Corporation of NZ Ltd [1991] NZHC 2680; (1991) 3 PRNZ 33 High Court of New Zealand New Zealand 11 Apr 1991 NZLII flag 30
Wellington International Airport Ltd v Commerce Commission [2013] NZHC 3289 High Court of New Zealand New Zealand 11 Dec 2013 NZLII flag 24
Wesfarmers Industrial & Safety New Zealand Ltd and Paykel Ltd; Decision No 502 [2003] NZComComm 17 New Zealand Commerce Commission New Zealand 26 Jun 2003 NZLII flag

Law Journal Articles Referring to this Case

Journal Article Title †  Citation(s) Author Jurisdiction Date Full Text Citation Index
""Pay for Delay": Legitimate Conduct to Defend Valid Patent Rights or Anticompetitive Behaviour?" [2018] VUWLawRw 2 Anning, Molly New Zealand circa 2018 NZLII flag
"The Impact of Economics on Competition Law in New Zealand: Some Reflections on the First Decade" [1996] VUWLawRw 2 Berry, Mark N New Zealand circa 1996 NZLII flag
"Dismantling the Grocery Duopoly: The Case for Prohibiting Grocery Covenants via Enforcement Action" [2023] VUWLawRw 23 Cable, Lara New Zealand circa 2023 NZLII flag
"Predatory Conduct under the Commerce Act 1986" [1998] VUWLawRw 31 Coull, David New Zealand circa 1998 NZLII flag
"A More Efficient Use of Efficiencies in Merger Authorisation Determinations" [2007] UMelbLRS 15 Duke, Arlen Australia circa 2007 AustLII flag
Case Commentary: Melway Publishing Pty Ltd v Robert Hicks Pty Ltd (2000) 6 High Court Review 1 Duns, John Australia circa 2000 AustLII flag
"Table of Cases" (1997) 16 (3) Australian Mining & Petroleum Law Journal 301 Editors Australia circa 1997 AustLII flag
"Application of Competition Principles to the Organisation of the Legal Profession, The" (1994) 17 University of New South Wales Law Journal 285 Farmer, James Australia circa 1994 AustLII flag
"Competition, Collaboration or Control: Competition Law and Tertiary Education in New Zealand" (2000) 8 Waikato Law Review 41 Kingsbury, Anna New Zealand circa 2000 NZLII flag
"Access to Essential Facilities under the Commerce Act in the Light of Experience in Australia, the European Union and the United States" [2000] VUWLawRw 19 Korah, Valentine New Zealand circa 2000 NZLII flag
"Legitimate Business Rationale and Section 36 of the Commerce Act 1986" (2018) 26 Waikato Law Review 96 Scott, Paul G New Zealand circa 2018 NZLII flag 1
"Price Fixing and the Doctrine of Ancillary Restraints" (1999) 7 Canterbury Law Review 403 Scott, Paul G New Zealand circa 1999 NZLII flag 2
"Unresolved Issues in Price Fixing: Market Division, the Meaning of Control and Characterisation" (2006) 12 Canterbury Law Review 197 Scott, Paul New Zealand circa 2006 NZLII flag
"Case Notes" (1990) 6 (3) Auckland University Law Review 453 Stone, Jonathan; van W Crommelin, Kurt; Murray, David; Campbell, Neil; Josling, Mike New Zealand circa 1990 NZLII flag
"Facilitating and Regulating Commerce" [2002] VUWLawRw 35 White QC, Douglas New Zealand circa 2002 NZLII flag

Legislation Cited

Legislation Name Provision
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth) s27

Cases and Articles Cited

Case Name †  Citation(s) Court Jurisdiction Date Full Text Citation Index
"Franchising and the Commerce Act 1986 (1)" [1986] New Zealand Law Journal 349 New Zealand Law Journal New Zealand circa 1986 flag 3
(1987) 1 NZBLC 99-076 (1987) 1 NZBLC 99-076 New Zealand circa 1987 flag 1
[1977-8] Atpr (Com) 35-400 [1977-8] ATPR (Com) 35-400 Australia circa 1977 flag 2
Auckland Regional Authority v Mutual Rental Cars (Auckland Airport) Ltd [1987] NZHC 213; [1987] 2 NZLR 647; (1988) 2 NZBLC 103,041; (1987) 2 TCLR 141 High Court of New Zealand New Zealand 31 Jul 1987 NZLII flag 68
Fisher and Paykel Ltd v Commerce Commission HC Auckland CL42/89 [1989] NZHC 324; [1989] 2 NZLR 635; (1989) 1 PRNZ 644 High Court of New Zealand New Zealand 18 May 1989 NZLII flag 4
Merchandise Transport Ltd v British Transport Commission [1962] 2 QB 173; [1961] 3 All ER 495; [1961] 3 WLR 1358 United Kingdom circa 1962 LexisNexis / Westlaw flag 28
Re Ford Motor Co of Australia Ltd (1977) 32 FLR 65 Australia circa 1977 Legal Online / Westlaw flag 8
Standard Oil Co v United States 337 US 293; 93 L Ed 1371; 69 SCt 1051; 93 L Ed 2d 1371 United States Supreme Court United States 13 Jun 1949 WorldLII flag 191
Tru Tone Ltd v Festival Records Retail Marketing Ltd HC Auckland CL31/87 [1988] NZHC 2299; (1988) 2 TCLR 525; (1988) 2 NZBLC 103,081 High Court of New Zealand New Zealand 17 Feb 1988 NZLII flag 3

LawCite: Privacy | Disclaimers | Conditions of Use | Acknowledgements | Feedback