Herminio a Astorga, in his capacity as Vice-Mayor of Manila v Antonio J Villegas, in his capacity as Mayor of Manila, the Hon , the Executive Secretary, Abelardo Subido, in his capacity as Commissioner of Civil Service, Eduardo Quintos, in his capacity as Chief of Police of Manila, Manuel Cudiamat, in his capacity as City Treasurer of Manila, City of Manila, Jose Sembrano, Francisco Gatmaitan, Martin Isidro, Cesar Lucero, Paderes Tinoco, Leonardo Fugoso, Francis Yuseco, Apolonio Gener, Ambrocio Lorenzo, JR , Alfonso Mendoza, JR , Sergio Loyola, Gerino Tolentino, Mariano Magsalin, Eduardo Quintos, JR , Avelino Villacorta, Pablo Ocampo, Felicisimo Cabigao, Jose Brillantes, Jose Villanueva and Marina Francisco, in their capacities as members of the Municipal Board

Supreme Court of the Philippines

Philippines

30th April, 1974

Cases and Articles Cited