LawCite Search | LawCite Markup Tool | Help | Feedback

Law
Cite

Cases Referring to this Case | Law Reform Reports Referring to this Case | Law Journal Articles Referring to this Case | Legislation Cited | Cases and Articles Cited

Help

Western Union Telegraph Co v Kansas   flag  69

216 US 1; 54 L Ed 355; 30 SCt 190
United States Supreme Court
United States
17th January, 1910

Cases Referring to this Case

Case Name Citation(s) Court Jurisdiction Date †  Full Text Citation Index
Dennis v Higgins 498 US 439; 112 L Ed 2d 969; 111 SCt 865 United States Supreme Court United States 20 Feb 1991 WorldLII flag 55
Philly's v Byrne 732 F2d 87 United States Court of Appeals, Seventh Circuit United States 29 May 1984 WorldLII flag 15
Consolidated Freightways Corporation v Kassel 730 F2d 1139 United States Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit United States 27 Mar 1984 WorldLII flag 18
Western & Southern Life Ins Co v State Bd of Equalization of Cal 451 US 648; 68 L Ed 2d 514; 101 SCt 2070 United States Supreme Court United States 26 May 1981 WorldLII flag 75
Ahmedabad ST Xaviers College Society & Anr v Gujarat & Anr [1974] INSC 106; [1975] 1 SCR 173; (1974) 1 SCC 717; AIR 1974 SC 1389 Supreme Court of India India 26 Apr 1974 LIIofIndia flag 66
Garrity v New Jersey 385 US 493; 17 L Ed 2d 562; 87 SCt 616 United States Supreme Court United States 16 Jan 1967 WorldLII flag 245
Watson v Employers Liability Assurance Corporation 348 US 66; 99 L Ed 74; 75 SCt 166 United States Supreme Court United States 10 Jan 1955 WorldLII flag 64
Miller Bros Co v Maryland 347 US 340; 98 L Ed 744; 74 SCt 535 United States Supreme Court United States 3 May 1954 WorldLII flag 26
Bode v Barrett 344 US 583; 97 L Ed 567; 73 SCt 468 United States Supreme Court United States 6 Apr 1953 WorldLII flag 8
Bailey v Richardson 182 F2d 46; 86 USApp DC 248 United States Court of Appeals, District of Columbia Circuit United States - District of Columbia 5 Jun 1950 WorldLII flag 58
Bailey v Richardson [1949] USCADC 50 United States Court of Appeals, District of Columbia Circuit United States 3 Nov 1949 WorldLII flag
Freeman v Hewit 329 US 249; 91 L Ed 265; 67 SCt 274 United States Supreme Court United States 13 Jan 1947 WorldLII flag 68
McLeod v J E Dilworth Co 64 SCt 1030 United States Supreme Court United States 12 Jun 1944 WorldLII flag
Nelson v Sears, Roebuck & Co 312 US 359; 85 L Ed 888; 61 SCt 586 United States Supreme Court United States 17 Mar 1941 WorldLII flag 19
McGoldrick v Berwind-White Coal Mining Co 309 US 33; 84 L Ed 565; 60 SCt 388 United States Supreme Court United States 29 Jan 1940 WorldLII flag 46
South Carolina State Highway Dept v Barnwell Bros 303 US 177; 82 L Ed 734; 58 SCt 510; 82 L Ed 2d 734 United States Supreme Court United States 14 Feb 1938 WorldLII flag 97
Connecticut General Life Ins Co v Johnson 303 US 77; 82 L Ed 673; 58 SCt 436 United States Supreme Court United States 31 Jan 1938 WorldLII flag 22
James v Dravo Contracting Co 302 US 134; 82 L Ed 155; 58 SCt 208 United States Supreme Court United States 6 Dec 1937 WorldLII flag 107
Atlantic Refining Co v Virginia 302 US 22; 82 L Ed 24; 58 SCt 75 United States Supreme Court United States 8 Nov 1937 WorldLII flag 7
Phillips Petroleum Co v Jenkins 297 US 629; 80 L Ed 943; 56 SCt 611 United States Supreme Court United States 30 Mar 1936 WorldLII flag
Pacific Telephone & Telegraph Co v Tax Comm'n of Wash 297 US 403; 80 L Ed 760; 56 SCt 522 United States Supreme Court United States 2 Mar 1936 WorldLII flag 6
Johnson Oil Refining Co v Oklahoma 290 US 158; 78 L Ed 238; 54 SCt 152 United States Supreme Court United States 4 Dec 1933 WorldLII flag 10
Louis K Liggett Co v Lee 288 US 517; 77 L Ed 929; 53 SCt 481 United States Supreme Court United States 13 Mar 1933 WorldLII flag 23
Anglo-Chilean Nitrate Sales Corporation v Alabama 288 US 218; 77 L Ed 710; 53 SCt 373 United States Supreme Court United States 6 Feb 1933 WorldLII flag 17
Boston & Maine R Co v Armburg 285 US 234; 76 L Ed 729; 52 SCt 336 United States Supreme Court United States 14 Mar 1932 WorldLII flag 6
Furst v Brewster 282 US 493; 75 L Ed 478; 51 SCt 295 United States Supreme Court United States 24 Feb 1931 WorldLII flag 6
Railway Express Agency, Inc v Virginia 282 US 440; 75 L Ed 450; 51 SCt 201 United States Supreme Court United States 2 Feb 1931 WorldLII flag 13
United States v Chicago, M , St P & P R Co 282 US 311; 75 L Ed 359; 51 SCt 159 United States Supreme Court United States 5 Jan 1931 WorldLII flag 20
O'Gorman & Young, Inc v Hartford Fire Ins Co 282 US 251; 51 SCt 130; 75 L Ed 324 United States Supreme Court United States 5 Jan 1931 WorldLII flag 46
Interstate Busses Corporation v Holyoke Street R Co 273 US 45; 47 SCt 298; 71 L Ed 530 United States Supreme Court United States 3 Jan 1927 WorldLII flag 11
Hanover Fire Ins Co v Harding 272 US 494; 71 L Ed 372; 47 SCt 179 United States Supreme Court United States 23 Nov 1926 WorldLII flag 36
Frost & Frost Trucking Co v Railroad Commission 271 US 583; 70 L Ed 1101; 46 SCt 605 United States Supreme Court United States 7 Jun 1926 WorldLII flag 75
Fidelity & Deposit Co v Tafoya 270 US 426; 70 L Ed 664; 46 SCt 331 United States Supreme Court United States 15 Mar 1926 WorldLII flag 18
Frick v Pennsylvania 268 US 473; 69 L Ed 1058; 45 SCt 603 United States Supreme Court United States 1 Jun 1925 WorldLII flag 42
Shafer v Farmers' Grain Co 268 US 199; 268 US 189; 69 L Ed 909; 45 SCt 481 United States Supreme Court United States 4 May 1925 WorldLII flag 37
Missouri ex rel Burnes Nat Bank of St Joseph v Duncan 265 US 17; 68 L Ed 881; 44 SCt 427 United States Supreme Court United States 28 Apr 1924 WorldLII flag 4
Lemke v Farmers' Grain Co 258 US 50; 66 L Ed 458; 42 SCt 244 United States Supreme Court United States 27 Feb 1922 WorldLII flag 50
Dahnke-Walker Milling Co v Bondurant 257 US 290; 257 US 282; 66 L Ed 239; 42 SCt 106 United States Supreme Court United States 12 Dec 1921 WorldLII flag 103
Crescent Cotton Oil Co v Mississippi 257 US 129; 66 L Ed 166; 42 SCt 42 United States Supreme Court United States 14 Nov 1921 WorldLII flag 17
Bowman v Continental Oil Co 256 US 642; 65 L Ed 1139; 41 SCt 606; 65 L Ed II37 United States Supreme Court United States 6 Jun 1921 WorldLII flag 30
Board of Pub Util Comm'rs v Ynchausti & Co 251 US 401; 64 L Ed 327; 40 SCt 277 United States Supreme Court United States 1 Mar 1920 WorldLII flag 2
Maxwell v Bugbee 250 US 525; 63 L Ed 1124; 40 SCt 2 United States Supreme Court United States 27 Oct 1919 WorldLII flag 32
Postal Telegraph-Cable Co v Richmond 249 US 252; 63 L Ed 590; 39 SCt 265 United States Supreme Court United States 17 Mar 1919 WorldLII flag 16
Locomobile Co of America v Massachusetts 38 SCt 298 United States Supreme Court United States 19 Oct 1918 WorldLII flag 3
International Paper Co v Massachusetts 246 US 135; 62 L Ed 624; 38 SCt 292 United States Supreme Court United States 19 Oct 1918 WorldLII flag 25
Western Union Telegraph Co v Foster 247 US 105; 62 L Ed 1006; 38 SCt 438 United States Supreme Court United States 20 May 1918 WorldLII flag 34
Denver v Denver Union Water Co 246 US 178; 62 L Ed 649; 38 SCt 278 United States Supreme Court United States 4 Mar 1918 WorldLII flag 20
Locomobile Co of America v Massachusetts 38 SCt 298 United States Supreme Court United States 19 Oct 1918 WorldLII flag 3
Looney v Crane Co 245 US 178; 62 L Ed 230; 38 SCt 85 United States Supreme Court United States 3 May 1916 WorldLII flag 28
Mountain Timber Co v Washington 243 US 239; 243 US 219; 61 L Ed 685; 37 SCt 260 United States Supreme Court United States 2 Mar 1916 WorldLII flag 49
Kansas City, F S & M R Co v Botkin 240 US 227; 60 L Ed 617; 36 SCt 261 United States Supreme Court United States 21 Feb 1916 WorldLII flag 25
Equitable Life Assurance Soc of United States v Pennsylvania 238 US 143; 35 SCt 829; 59 L Ed 1239; 58 L Ed 1239 United States Supreme Court United States 14 Jun 1915 WorldLII flag 10
St Louis Southwestern Ry Co v Arkansas 235 US 350; 59 L Ed 265; 35 SCt 99 United States Supreme Court United States 7 Dec 1914 WorldLII flag 62
Sioux Remedy Co v Cope 235 US 197; 59 L Ed 193; 35 SCt 57 United States Supreme Court United States 30 Nov 1914 WorldLII flag 29
New York Life Insurance Co v Head 234 US 149; 58 L Ed 1259; 34 SCt 879 United States Supreme Court United States 8 Jun 1914 WorldLII flag 18
Sault Ste Marie v International Transit Co 234 US 333; 58 L Ed 1337; 34 SCt 826; 52 LRANS 574 United States Supreme Court United States 8 Jun 1914 WorldLII flag 4
Singer Sewing Machine Co v Brickell 233 US 304; 58 L Ed 974; 34 SCt 493 United States Supreme Court United States 6 Apr 1914 WorldLII flag 13
Harrison v St Louis & San Francisco R Co 232 US 318; 58 L Ed 621; 34 SCt 333 United States Supreme Court United States 24 Feb 1914 WorldLII flag 20
Baltic Mining Co v Massachusetts 231 US 68; 58 L Ed 127; 34 SCt 15 United States Supreme Court United States 3 Nov 1913 WorldLII flag 22
Minnesota Rate Cases (Simpson v Shepard) 230 US 352; 48 LRANS 1151; 57 L Ed 154; 57 L Ed 1511; 33 SCt 729 United States Supreme Court United States 9 Jun 1913 WorldLII flag 184
Williams v City of Talladega 226 US 404; 57 L Ed 275; 33 SCt 116 United States Supreme Court United States 23 Dec 1912 WorldLII flag 15
Atchison, T & SFR Co v O'Connor 223 US 287; 223 US 280; 56 L Ed 436; 32 SCt 216 United States Supreme Court United States 19 Feb 1912 WorldLII flag 43
Flint v Stone Tracy Co 220 US 107; 31 SCt 342; 55 L Ed 389; 55 L Ed 589 United States Supreme Court United States 13 Mar 1911 WorldLII flag 135
Chicago, R I & P R Co v Arkansas 219 US 453; 55 L Ed 290; 31 SCt 275 United States Supreme Court United States 20 Feb 1911 WorldLII flag 20
Herndon v Chicago, R I & P R Co 218 US 135; 54 L Ed 970; 30 SCt 633 United States Supreme Court United States 31 May 1910 WorldLII flag 20
International Textbook Co v Pigg 217 US 91; 18 Ann Cas 1103; 27 LRANS 493; 54 L Ed 678; 30 SCt 481; 24 LRANS 493 United States Supreme Court United States - New York 4 Apr 1910 WorldLII flag 53
Ludwig v Western Union Telegraph Co 216 US 146; 54 L Ed 423; 30 SCt 280 United States Supreme Court United States 21 Feb 1910 WorldLII flag 27
Southern R Co v Greene 216 US 400; 54 L Ed 536; 17 Ann Cas 1247; 30 SCt 287; 17 A & E Ann Cas 1247 United States Supreme Court United States - New York 21 Feb 1910 WorldLII flag 45
Pullman Co v Kansas 216 US 56; 54 L Ed 378; 30 SCt 232 United States Supreme Court United States 31 Jan 1910 WorldLII flag 33

Cases and Articles Cited

Case Name Citation(s) Court Jurisdiction Date †  Full Text Citation Index
United States v Delaware & Hudson Co 213 US 366; 53 L Ed 836; 29 SCt 527 United States Supreme Court United States 3 May 1909 WorldLII flag 133
Galveston, Harrisburg & San Antonio Ry Co v Texas 210 US 227; 210 US 217; 52 L Ed 1031; 28 SCt 638 United States Supreme Court United States 18 May 1908 WorldLII flag 71
Asbell v Kansas 209 US 251; 14 Ann Cas 1101; 52 L Ed 778; 28 SCt 485; 14 A & E Ann Cas 1101 United States Supreme Court United States 23 Mar 1908 WorldLII flag 28
Union Bridge Co v United States 204 US 364; 51 L Ed 523; 27 SCt 367 United States Supreme Court United States 25 Feb 1907 WorldLII flag 53
National Council of Junior Order of United American Mechanics of United States v State Council of Va , Junior Order of United American Mechanics of Va 203 US 151; 51 L Ed 132; 27 SCt 46 United States Supreme Court United States 19 Nov 1906 WorldLII flag 6
Security Mutual Life Ins Co v Prewitt 202 US 246; 50 L Ed 1013; 6 A & E Ann Cas 317; 6 Ann Cas 317; 26 SCt 619 United States Supreme Court United States 14 May 1906 WorldLII flag 12
Manigault v Springs 199 US 473; 50 L Ed 274; 26 SCt 127 United States Supreme Court United States 4 Dec 1905 WorldLII flag 43
Union Refrigerator Transit Co v Kentucky 199 US 206; 199 US 194; 4 Ann Cas 493; 4 A & E Ann Cas 493; 50 L Ed 150; 26 SCt 36 United States Supreme Court United States 13 Nov 1905 WorldLII flag 61
Allen v Pullman's Palace Car Co 191 US 171; 48 L Ed 134; 24 SCt 39 United States Supreme Court United States 16 Nov 1903 WorldLII flag 9
Pullman Co v Adams 189 US 434; 189 US 420; 47 L Ed 887; 23 SCt 531 United States Supreme Court United States 2 Mar 1903 WorldLII flag 26
Caldwell v North Carolina 187 US 622; 47 L Ed 336; 23 SCt 229 United States Supreme Court United States 12 Jan 1903 WorldLII flag 23
Stockard v Morgan 185 US 27; 46 L Ed 785; 22 SCt 576 United States Supreme Court United States 7 Apr 1902 WorldLII flag 13
Louisville & Jeffersonville Ferry Co v Kentucky 188 US 385; 47 L Ed 513; 23 SCt 463 United States Supreme Court United States 17 Jan 1902 WorldLII flag 24
Waters-Pierce Oil Co v Texas 177 US 28; 44 L Ed 657; 20 SCt 518 United States Supreme Court United States 19 Mar 1900 WorldLII flag 17
Lake Shore & Michigan Southern R Co v Ohio 173 US 285; 43 L Ed 702; 19 SCt 465 United States Supreme Court United States 20 Feb 1899 WorldLII flag 39
Barrow Steamship Co v Kane 170 US 100; 42 L Ed 964; 18 SCt 526 United States Supreme Court United States 11 Apr 1898 WorldLII flag 33
Missouri, K & T R Co v Haber 169 US 613; 42 L Ed 878; 18 SCt 488 United States Supreme Court United States 14 Mar 1898 WorldLII flag 38
New York, N H & H R Co v New York 165 US 628; 41 L Ed 853; 17 SCt 418 United States Supreme Court United States 1 Mar 1897 WorldLII flag 39
Osborne v Florida 164 US 650; 41 L Ed 586; 17 SCt 214 United States Supreme Court United States 4 Jan 1897 WorldLII flag 17
Postal Telegraph Cable Co v Adams 155 US 688; 39 L Ed 311; 15 SCt 268 United States Supreme Court United States 21 Jan 1895 WorldLII flag 41
Hooper v California 155 US 648; 39 L Ed 297; 15 SCt 207 United States Supreme Court United States 7 Jan 1895 WorldLII flag 85
Ashley v Ryan 153 US 436; 38 L Ed 773; 14 SCt 865 United States Supreme Court United States 14 May 1894 WorldLII flag 12
Brennan v Titusville 153 US 289; 38 L Ed 719; 14 SCt 829 United States Supreme Court United States 30 Apr 1894 WorldLII flag 30
Martin's Administrator v Baltimore & Ohio R Co 151 US 673; 38 L Ed 311; 14 SCt 533 United States Supreme Court United States 5 Feb 1894 WorldLII flag 41
Southern Pac Co v Denton 146 US 202; 36 L Ed 942; 13 SCt 44 United States Supreme Court United States 21 Nov 1892 WorldLII flag 48
Horn Silver Mining Co v New York 143 US 305; 36 L Ed 164; 12 SCt 403 United States Supreme Court United States 29 Feb 1892 WorldLII flag 15
Crutcher v Kentucky 141 US 47; 35 L Ed 649; 11 SCt 851 United States Supreme Court United States 25 May 1891 WorldLII flag 66
Brimmer v Rebman 138 US 78; 35 L Ed 862; 34 L Ed 862; 11 SCt 213 United States Supreme Court United States 19 Jan 1891 WorldLII flag 32
Norfolk & Western R Co v Pennsylvania 136 US 114; 34 L Ed 394; 10 SCt 958 United States Supreme Court United States 19 May 1890 WorldLII flag 14
Minnesota v Barber 136 US 313; 34 L Ed 455; 10 SCt 862; 24 L Ed 455 United States Supreme Court United States 19 May 1890 WorldLII flag 60
McCall v California 136 US 104; 34 L Ed 391; 34 L Ed 392; 10 SCt 881 United States Supreme Court United States 19 May 1890 WorldLII flag 29
Lyng v Michigan 135 US 161; 34 L Ed 150; 10 SCt 725 United States Supreme Court United States 28 Apr 1890 WorldLII flag 17
Stoutenburgh v Hennick 129 US 141; 32 L Ed 637; 9 SCt 256 United States Supreme Court United States 14 Jan 1889 WorldLII flag 36
Asher v Texas 128 US 129; 32 L Ed 368; 9 SCt 1 United States Supreme Court United States 29 Oct 1888 WorldLII flag 19
Nashville, C & St L R Co v Alabama 128 US 96; 32 L Ed 352; 9 SCt 28 United States Supreme Court United States 22 Oct 1888 WorldLII flag 36
Ratterman v Western Union Tel Co 127 US 411; 32 L Ed 229; 8 SCt 1127 United States Supreme Court United States 14 May 1888 WorldLII flag 28
Leloup v Port of Mobile 127 US 640; 8 SCt 1380; 32 L Ed 311 United States Supreme Court United States 14 May 1888 WorldLII flag 67
Western Union Telegraph Co v Massachusetts 125 US 530; 8 SCt 961; 31 L Ed 790; 31 L Ed 709 United States Supreme Court United States 19 Mar 1888 WorldLII flag 43
Smith v Alabama 124 US 465; 31 L Ed 508; 8 SCt 564 United States Supreme Court United States 30 Jan 1888 WorldLII flag 71
Mugler v Kansas 123 US 623-672; 123 US 623; 31 L Ed 205; 8 SCt 273; 5 L Ed 2d 225 United States Supreme Court United States 5 Dec 1887 WorldLII flag 154
Philadelphia & Southern MSS Co v Pennsylvania 122 US 326; 30 L Ed 1200; 7 SCt 1118; 7 SCt 118 United States Supreme Court United States 27 May 1887 WorldLII flag 63
Barron v Burnside 121 US 186; 7 SCt 931; 30 L Ed 915 United States Supreme Court United States 11 Apr 1887 WorldLII flag 18
Robbins v Shelby County Taxing District 120 US 489; 30 L Ed 694; 7 SCt 592 United States Supreme Court United States 7 Mar 1887 WorldLII flag 102
Morgan's S S Co v Louisiana Bd of Health 118 US 455; 30 L Ed 237; 6 SCt 1114 United States Supreme Court United States 10 May 1886 WorldLII flag 41
Pickard v Car Co 117 US 34; 29 L Ed 785; 6 SCt 635 United States Supreme Court United States 1 Mar 1886 WorldLII flag 27
Walling v Michigan 116 US 446; 29 L Ed 691; 6 SCt 454 United States Supreme Court United States 18 Jan 1886 WorldLII flag 44
Gloucester Ferry Co v Pennsylvania 114 US 196; 29 L Ed 158; 5 SCt 826 United States Supreme Court United States 13 Apr 1885 WorldLII flag 69
St Clair v Cox 106 US 350; 27 L Ed 222; 1 SCt 354; 16 Ot 350 United States Supreme Court United States 18 Dec 1882 WorldLII flag 39
Telegraph Co v Texas 105 US 460; 26 L Ed 1067 United States Supreme Court United States 1 Oct 1881 WorldLII flag 47
County of Mobile v Kimball 102 US 691; 26 L Ed 238; 12 Ot 691 United States Supreme Court United States 1 Oct 1880 WorldLII flag 84
Cook v Pennsylvania 97 US 566; 24 L Ed 1015 United States Supreme Court United States 1 Oct 1878 WorldLII flag 31
Pensacola Telegraph Co v Western Union Telegraph Co 96 US 1; 24 L Ed 708 United States Supreme Court United States 1 Oct 1877 WorldLII flag 56
Inman S S Co v Tinker 94 US 238; 24 L Ed 118 United States Supreme Court United States 1 Oct 1876 WorldLII flag 9
Sherlock v Alling 93 US 99; 23 L Ed 819; 44 Ind 184; 3 Ot 99 United States Supreme Court United States 1 Oct 1876 WorldLII flag 59
Welton v Missouri 91 US 275; 1 Ot 275; 23 L Ed 347 United States Supreme Court United States 1 Oct 1875 WorldLII flag 100
Henderson v Mayor of New York 92 US 259; 23 L Ed 543; 2 Ot 259 United States Supreme Court United States 1 Oct 1875 WorldLII flag 66
Insurance Co v Morse 87 US 445; 20 Wall 445; 22 L Ed 365 United States Supreme Court United States 1 Oct 1874 WorldLII flag 47
Paul v Virginia (1869) 75 US 168; 19 L Ed 357; 8 Wall 168 United States Supreme Court United States 1 Dec 1868 WorldLII flag 161
Dobbins v Commissioners of Erie County 41 US 435; 10 L Ed 1022; 16 Pet 435 United States Supreme Court United States 1 Jan 1842 WorldLII flag 48
Bank of Augusta v Earle 38 US 519; 13 Pet 519; 10 L Ed 274; 588-10 L Ed 274 United States Supreme Court United States 1 Jan 1839 WorldLII flag 98
Weston v Charleston 27 US 449; (1829) 2 Pet 449; 7 L Ed 481 United States Supreme Court United States 1 Jan 1829 WorldLII flag 102
Brown v Maryland 25 US 419; (1827) 12 Wheat 419; 6 L Ed 678 United States Supreme Court United States 12 Mar 1827 WorldLII flag 178
Browne v Turner 176 Mass 9; 56 NE 969 United States - Massachusetts circa 1906 flag 3
Western U Teleg Co v Atty Gen 125 US 549 United States Supreme Court United States circa 1906 Westlaw flag 1
53 Lra 921 53 LRA 921 United States circa 1906 flag 2
24 How 169 24 How 169 United Stated Supreme Court United States circa 1906 flag 28
23 SCt 494 23 SCt 494 United States circa 1906 Westlaw flag 5
Lafayette Ins Co v French 18 How 404 United Stated Supreme Court United States circa 1906 flag 55
15 SCt 268 15 SCt 268 United States circa 1906 Westlaw flag 27
Bank of Augusta v Earle 13 Pet 539 United States Supreme Court United States circa 1906 flag 1
Cooley v Part Wardens 12 How 299 United Stated Supreme Court United States circa 1906 flag 186

LawCite: Privacy | Disclaimers | Conditions of Use | Acknowledgements | Feedback